Unanswered Doesn't talk to child aftet exiting new narakort? Unanswered What do I do, I'm stuck in chapter 4? Answered The Witcher "How" do I level up my influence? Unanswered How do I increase my influence in bargaining for more coins? Ask A Question.
Keep me logged in on this device. Forgot your username or password? Of monsters and men - the mob for Abigail won't show up? Beastmode engaged! Launch the beastmissile. Prepare the beasthowitzer. Get into beast formation men and charge that fort! Really interesting to read how people perceived Abigail's quest and also getting into detail of what happened and happens depending on what you do. The title is a bit spoilery though. I hope nobody who hasn't played TW1 stumbles upon this thread.
The outcome of all the villagers dying does not make sense in a light of what Geralt told the Reverend people who are dead do not have second chances , the beast not having time to run around and kill every peasant Geralt fights it as soon as it appears , and because peasants would be in their houses after dark. I don't really know what the devs intended concerning this quest. It can go either way, with good reasons on both sides. What I object is to a seemingly unanimous agreement judging by a scarcity of youtube videos illustrating this choice that to save Abigail is a right thing to do.
I actually liked siding-with-the-villagers. Geralt makes the Reverend shut up and demands a trial so there is no lynching , tells Abigail that he is tired of this crap, and they should sort it out without his help.
She curses him by a lionhead spider, which shows who she really is. The cult makes bloody sacrifices for its cruel god and the priestesses are known for their powerful curses.
He kills the beast with the help of the villagers alive and well, by the way , and when he tells the Reverend it was a vile thing to give up the children, the Reverend told he did not have a choice.
He and it is not a stretch to say everyone else who resisted salamandra demands would be killed otherwise. I would say if to pretend that the villagers are alive, and free from salamandra and a lionheadspider witch, it is a pretty good outcome.
HeelPower Rookie 14 Dec 31, So the villagers ALL die when you side with Abigail? From what I recall you are forced to fight the reverend and his goons should you side with her. I can't recall that all the villagers in the outskirts die.
Anyway, the reason I sided with Abigail is I found the reverend's gang to be more consistently evil just by comparison. She provided them with their tools ,sure but she didn't design or commit the crimes per se. The sex in the cave makes zero sense to be honest. Idk how that element is to be taken seriously.
CostinRaz Banned 15 Dec 31, Geralt makes sure she is not lynched even if he chooses the peasants. And yes, all people die besides corpses all over, including women's, we have a dialog with Shani about all villagers being dead, does not matter what we choose , which I found extremely weird. I can understand if Geralt had to face a mob not just the Reverend and his lackeys and killed them all in self-defense he is a butcher of Blaviken after all , but not if he chose to help them. Alyza said:. Spoiler Geralt killed Renfri's band who were just getting together and they didn't have their weapons out and they looked completely innocent.
He decided to do this once he figured out their intention to massacre the village but he looked like he just murdered completely innocent group and people hated him for it hence the nickname. Gilrond-i-Virdan Mentor 19 Dec 31, Abigail cursing Geralt out of desperation in case when he doesn't help her is natural and expected from her.
Geralt not helping her is a pretty cowardly and wrong choice. Phosphorus in particular. Bomb making ingredients. Barghest skulls. Wolf pelts. Basilisk hides. Fleder fangs. Other notes If Abigail dies, a vial of Specter Oil can be looted from her corpse.
If Abigail lives, she will be the healer in Chapter IV. The Heat of the Day quest plays out differently depending on whether she lives or dies. The player can choose to have sex with her, and gets a sex card in doing so. She has Berengar's notes on the Beast. It's possible that she influenced the merchant to kill his brother as she has a suspicious doll of his likeness in her hut.
Trending Posts. V Venom31 The Witcher I am sure that many rescued her! These children they sacrificed to their God or bring up in their temples as future Ministers. Sort by:. K Kaer T Toxa95 N Neoplayg
0コメント